AIThis post was created with the assistance of artificial intelligence (AI).

For fans seeking the best Nintendo Mario games, the options can be overwhelming, with classics and new titles offering different experiences. Super Mario Odyssey stands out as the overall favorite for its innovative open-world gameplay, while Super Mario Galaxy offers a beloved 3D platforming experience that’s hard to beat. Meanwhile, titles like Super Mario Maker 2 appeal to creative players who want to design their own worlds. The main tradeoffs often involve balancing nostalgia with innovation and determining whether to prioritize single-player adventures or multiplayer fun. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown to help find the perfect Mario game for your play style.

11
compared
3
brands
Which Nintendo Mario game should you buy?
★ Top Pick
Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder
Best Overall for Innovative 2D Platforming
Large cast of characters including Mario, Luigi, Peach, Daisy
See on Amazon →
Players who enjoy exploring expansive worlds and experimenting with new mechanics in 3D platformers.
Super Mario Odyssey
Vast and colorful kingdoms with hidden secrets
View on Amazon →
Fans of classic Mario platformers who want a polished, accessible experience with story and visuals improved for Switch.
Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Ma
Enjoys two beloved Mario space adventures with enhanced visuals
View on Amazon →
Retro fans or newcomers seeking a broad overview of classic 3D Mario titles on Switch.
Super Mario 3D All-Stars
Includes three classic Mario games in one package
View on Amazon →
Explorers who love discovering secrets and experimenting with creative gameplay in 3D worlds.
Super Mario Odyssey
Vast and colorful 3D worlds to explore
View on Amazon →
Pros & cons at a glance
Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder
✓ Large cast of characters including Mario, Luigi, Peach, Daisy
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting accessibility for non-Switch owners
Super Mario Odyssey
✓ Vast and colorful kingdoms with hidden secrets
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting portability
Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Ma
✓ Enjoys two beloved Mario space adventures with enhanced visuals
✗ No physical edition or physical extras included
Super Mario 3D All-Stars
✓ Includes three classic Mario games in one package
✗ Does not come with original case or manuals
Super Mario Odyssey
✓ Vast and colorful 3D worlds to explore
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting portability
Mario Party Superstars
✓ Includes iconic Nintendo 64 boards and mini-games for authentic nostalgia
✗ Limited to Nintendo Switch, restricting platform flexibility
New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe
✓ Includes new characters with unique abilities for varied gameplay
✗ Challenging difficulty may deter very young or new players
Super Mario RPG
✓ Vibrant, colorful visuals evoke nostalgic charm
✗ Limited information on multiplayer features, likely single-player only
Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’
✓ Includes two popular Mario games in one package
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch console for play
Super Mario Maker 2
✓ Robust course creation and customization tools
✗ Requires Nintendo Switch Online membership for online features
Super Mario 3D All-Stars
✓ Enhanced graphics bring new life to classic gameplay
✗ Region-specific restrictions limit access for some players

Complete the kit

GIOTOHUN Cat Water Fountain Filter: 12 Cat Fountain Filte...
GIOTOHUN Cat Water Fountain Filter: 12 Cat Fountain Filte…
Add to your setup →
Bluevua Official RO100ROPOT 4-Pack Replacement Filter Set...
Bluevua Official RO100ROPOT 4-Pack Replacement Filter Set…
Add to your setup →
Core Mini Replacement Filter for LEVOIT Core Mini,Core Mi...
Core Mini Replacement Filter for LEVOIT Core Mini,Core Mi…
Add to your setup →

Key Takeaways

  • The top picks balance classic gameplay with modern innovations, appealing to both longtime fans and newcomers.
  • Most titles excel in either single-player storytelling or multiplayer versatility, which influences their ranking.
  • The Nintendo Switch offers the most recent and versatile Mario experiences, but some older titles still hold significant appeal.
  • Replay value varies greatly, with games like Super Mario Odyssey and Super Mario Maker 2 offering extensive content and creative freedom.
  • Price and platform availability are key considerations; some titles are included in bundles or services, offering better value.
2
Super Mario Odyssey
Best for 3D Exploration and Adventure
1
Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder
Best Overall for Innovative 2D Platforming
3
Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Ma
Best for Classic Space Adventure Fans

Our Top Best Nintendo Mario Games Picks

Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder – Nintendo Switch (US Version)Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder - Nintendo Switch (US Version)Best Overall for Innovative 2D PlatformingPlatform: Nintendo SwitchVersion: US VersionGenre: PlatformerVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario Odyssey – US VersionSuper Mario Odyssey - US VersionBest for 3D Exploration and AdventurePlatform: Nintendo SwitchMultiplayer: Yes, local multiplayerIncluded accessories: Joy-Con controllers, amiibo figuresVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2Best for Classic Space Adventure FansPlatform: Nintendo SwitchIncludes: Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario Galaxy 2Enhanced visuals: YesVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario 3D All-Stars – Nintendo Switch (Renewed)Super Mario 3D All-Stars - Nintendo Switch (Renewed)Best for Nostalgic Collection of Classic 3D Mario GamesPlatform: Nintendo SwitchIncludes: Super Mario 64, Sunshine, GalaxyCondition: RenewedVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo SwitchSuper Mario Odyssey - Nintendo SwitchBest for Open-World 3D Exploration & MultiplayerPlatform: Nintendo SwitchMultiplayer: Yes, local multiplayerIncludes: Digital code, amiibo figuresVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Mario Party Superstars – US VersionMario Party Superstars - US VersionBest for Classic Multiplayer FunNumber of Boards: 5Number of Minigames: 100Online Play: YesVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe – US VersionNew Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe - US VersionBest for Newcomers and Cooperative PlayPlatform: Nintendo SwitchModes: Single-player, MultiplayerCharacters: Mario, Luigi, Toadette, Nabbit, Mii charactersVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario RPG – Nintendo Switch (US Version)Super Mario RPG - Nintendo Switch (US Version)Best for Classic Turn-Based RPG FansVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury – US VersionSuper Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury - US VersionBest for Dual-Adventure EnthusiastsPlatform: Nintendo SwitchGame Type: Action, AdventureMultiplayer: Local and online multiplayerVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario Maker 2 – US VersionSuper Mario Maker 2 - US VersionBest for Creative Builders and Community SharingPlatform: Nintendo SwitchModes: Single-player, MultiplayerFeatures: Course creation, Online sharing, Community access, Software updatesVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Super Mario 3D All-Stars (European Version)Super Mario 3D All-Stars (European Version)Best for Nostalgic Fans Seeking a Classic Collection with Modern TouchesPlatform: Nintendo SwitchIncluded Games: Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, Super Mario GalaxyGraphics Update: YesVIEW LATEST PRICESee Our Full Breakdown
Specs at a glance

More Details on Our Top Picks

  1. Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder – Nintendo Switch (US Version)

    Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder - Nintendo Switch (US Version)

    Best Overall for Innovative 2D Platforming

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder stands out as the most complete experience in the lineup, offering a fresh take on classic side-scrolling action. Its introduction of Wonder Flowers and new power-ups injects unpredictability into the familiar gameplay, making it ideal for both longtime fans and newcomers seeking innovation. Compared with Super Mario 3D All-Stars, which offers nostalgic remasters, this game provides modern mechanics and a large cast, but it requires a Nintendo Switch console and may present a learning curve for those unfamiliar with the controls. The inclusion of characters like Nabbit and colorful Yoshi variants broadens its appeal, especially for players who enjoy varied gameplay styles. The only tradeoffs are that it’s exclusive to Switch and might seem complex initially for casual players. Overall, this pick makes the most sense for players wanting a fresh, feature-rich Mario experience on modern hardware.

    Pros:
    • Large cast of characters including Mario, Luigi, Peach, Daisy
    • Innovative gameplay with Wonder Flowers and new power-ups
    • Includes new characters like Nabbit and Yoshi variants
    Cons:
    • Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting accessibility for non-Switch owners
    • May have a learning curve for players unfamiliar with new mechanics

    Best for: Fans who want a new, innovative 2D Mario adventure with modern gameplay mechanics.

    Not ideal for: Players seeking a straightforward, nostalgic experience without learning new features or mechanics.

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Version:US Version
    • Genre:Platformer
    • Features:Multiple characters, new power-ups, Wonder Flowers
    Our verdict
    “This game is perfect for those seeking a fresh, feature-packed 2D Mario experience on Switch.”
  2. Super Mario Odyssey – US Version

    Super Mario Odyssey - US Version

    Best for 3D Exploration and Adventure

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario Odyssey makes the list for its expansive, vibrant kingdoms that redefine 3D platforming. Its innovative Cappy capture mechanic radically changes how Mario interacts with environments, offering a creative twist that sets it apart from the more linear Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2. While it supports multiplayer with Joy-Con controllers, some players might find the gameplay repetitive after exploring the diverse worlds. The game’s colorful design and hidden secrets make it ideal for explorers and casual players but could be less appealing for those craving a focused challenge or linear story. The inclusion of amiibo figures adds replay value, but the game requires a Switch console and may feel long for players who prefer shorter, more structured experiences. This title is best suited for players seeking a broad, open-ended Mario adventure with multiplayer options.

    Pros:
    • Vast and colorful kingdoms with hidden secrets
    • Innovative gameplay with Cappy’s capture mechanic
    • Supports multiplayer for shared fun
    • Includes additional content via amiibo figures
    Cons:
    • Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting portability
    • Some may find the gameplay repetitive over long sessions

    Best for: Players who enjoy exploring expansive worlds and experimenting with new mechanics in 3D platformers.

    Not ideal for: Gamers preferring tight, linear gameplay or those uninterested in exploration-heavy titles.

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Multiplayer:Yes, local multiplayer
    • Included accessories:Joy-Con controllers, amiibo figures
    Our verdict
    “Ideal for players who love exploring large, vibrant worlds and experimenting with creative gameplay mechanics.”
  3. Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2

    Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2

    Best for Classic Space Adventure Fans

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2 offers a dual-pack of beloved space-themed adventures with enhanced visuals and additional content, making it ideal for fans of the original games or newcomers wanting a comprehensive package. Compared to Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury, which emphasizes multiplayer and open-world segments, these Galaxy titles excel in tight, focused platforming with innovative gravity mechanics. The addition of Assist Mode helps ease difficulty, but some players may prefer the original versions without the enhanced UI and visual upgrades. While it requires a Switch to play, the package’s accessibility and nostalgic appeal make it a strong choice for those wanting to experience Mario’s space adventures with a modern touch. It’s particularly suitable for players who value classic gameplay with added convenience.

    Pros:
    • Enjoys two beloved Mario space adventures with enhanced visuals
    • Additional content and storybook chapters enrich gameplay
    • Assist Mode offers extra health and fall recovery
    Cons:
    • No physical edition or physical extras included
    • Some may prefer original versions without graphical updates
    • Requires Nintendo Switch console

    Best for: Fans of classic Mario platformers who want a polished, accessible experience with story and visuals improved for Switch.

    Not ideal for: Players seeking a more open-world or multiplayer-centric Mario experience.

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Includes:Super Mario Galaxy and Super Mario Galaxy 2
    • Enhanced visuals:Yes
    • Additional content:Storybook chapters
    • Features:Improved UI, Assist Mode
    Our verdict
    “Perfect for fans wanting a polished, nostalgic space adventure package with modern enhancements.”
  4. Super Mario 3D All-Stars – Nintendo Switch (Renewed)

    Super Mario 3D All-Stars - Nintendo Switch (Renewed)

    Best for Nostalgic Collection of Classic 3D Mario Games

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario 3D All-Stars delivers a curated collection of three iconic 3D Mario titles—Super Mario 64, Sunshine, and Galaxy—making it ideal for fans wanting a portable, nostalgic trip. Compared to Super Mario Odyssey, which offers a more modern 3D experience, this bundle emphasizes the original gameplay styles and classic design. Its main drawbacks are the absence of original packaging and the fact that it’s a renewed product, which might have cosmetic imperfections. While it doesn’t include physical manuals or cases, the bundled games provide a comprehensive look at Mario’s evolution. This set suits players seeking a nostalgic compilation or those new to Mario’s 3D adventures who want a quick overview of the series’ roots, but it’s less suitable for those wanting the latest gameplay innovations.

    Pros:
    • Includes three classic Mario games in one package
    • Playable on Nintendo Switch in handheld or tabletop modes
    • Features motion controls and co-op options
    Cons:
    • Does not come with original case or manuals
    • Game cartridge only, no physical packaging
    • Renewed product may have cosmetic imperfections

    Best for: Retro fans or newcomers seeking a broad overview of classic 3D Mario titles on Switch.

    Not ideal for: Players who prioritize new gameplay mechanics or graphical updates over nostalgia.

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Includes:Super Mario 64, Sunshine, Galaxy
    • Condition:Renewed
    • Additional features:Motion controls, two-player Co-Star mode
    Our verdict
    “Great for nostalgia-driven players or those wanting a compact, versatile collection of Mario’s 3D classics.”
  5. Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch

    Super Mario Odyssey - Nintendo Switch

    Best for Open-World 3D Exploration & Multiplayer

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario Odyssey earns its spot for its expansive, colorful worlds and innovative capture mechanic, making it a standout among 3D Mario games. Its vibrant locales like New Donk City and detailed secrets offer hours of exploration, similar to the expansive design of Super Mario Galaxy™ + Super Mario Galaxy™ 2. While the game supports local multiplayer and includes amiibo unlockables, some players may find the storyline predictable, and the digital code format might be less convenient. The game’s focus on exploration and creative interaction makes it ideal for players who enjoy open-ended gameplay, but those looking for a shorter or more structured experience might find it less appealing. It’s best suited for players wanting a dynamic, multiplayer-friendly 3D Mario adventure.

    Pros:
    • Vast and colorful 3D worlds to explore
    • Innovative gameplay with Cappy’s capture mechanic
    • Multiplayer mode for shared fun
    Cons:
    • Requires Nintendo Switch console, limiting portability
    • Digital code may require redemption
    • Storyline can feel predictable for some players

    Best for: Explorers who love discovering secrets and experimenting with creative gameplay in 3D worlds.

    Not ideal for: Gamers preferring linear, story-driven experiences or those uninterested in multiplayer features.

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Multiplayer:Yes, local multiplayer
    • Includes:Digital code, amiibo figures
    Our verdict
    “Best for players who enjoy exploring open worlds and experimenting with creative Mario mechanics in multiplayer settings.”
  6. Mario Party Superstars – US Version

    Mario Party Superstars - US Version

    Best for Classic Multiplayer Fun

    View Latest Price

    This collection of 5 Nintendo 64 boards and 100 minigames makes Mario Party Superstars stand out for fans craving nostalgic multiplayer experiences. Compared with Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury, which emphasizes cooperative platforming, this title offers a more social and competitive edge, especially with online multiplayer and save progress features. While it supports multiple controllers and online play, it’s limited solely to the Switch platform and lacks new content beyond the classic boards. The game’s strengths lie in its authentic recreation of beloved mini-games, making it ideal for group play, but it may feel repetitive for those seeking fresh content or single-player depth. If your priority is multiplayer party mode with a nostalgic twist, this pick makes the most sense.

    Pros:
    • Includes iconic Nintendo 64 boards and mini-games for authentic nostalgia
    • Supports online multiplayer with save progress for seamless play
    • Compatible with various controllers including Joy-Con and Pro Controller
    Cons:
    • Limited to Nintendo Switch, restricting platform flexibility
    • No new gameplay content beyond classic boards and mini-games
    • Price details are not specified, which might affect purchase decisions

    Best for: Players who enjoy multiplayer party games with friends or family, especially fans of classic Nintendo 64 titles

    Not ideal for: Solo players or those seeking a story-driven experience, as it focuses on multiplayer mini-games and lacks a narrative

    • Number of Boards:5
    • Number of Minigames:100
    • Online Play:Yes
    • Controller Compatibility:Joy-Con, Joy-Con Grip, Pro Controller, Switch Lite
    Our verdict
    “This game is perfect for nostalgic multiplayer fun, especially for groups that enjoy classic Nintendo mini-games.”
  7. New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe – US Version

    New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe - US Version

    Best for Newcomers and Cooperative Play

    View Latest Price

    New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe offers a classic 2D side-scrolling experience with added character options like Toadette and Nabbit, making it more accessible than the more challenging Super Mario RPG. Compared to Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury, which introduces 3D platforming and more complex levels, this game is straightforward and better suited for players new to Mario or looking for cooperative fun. Its variety of modes, including Boost Rush and Challenges, adds replay value, but the game can be tough for very young or inexperienced players due to its difficulty levels. It requires a Nintendo Switch and is best for those who want a cooperative, family-friendly platformer. If you’re after a traditional Mario experience with local multiplayer, this makes a compelling choice.

    Pros:
    • Includes new characters with unique abilities for varied gameplay
    • Multiple modes enhance replayability and challenge
    • Helpful features like Hints gallery and Super Guide assist less experienced players
    Cons:
    • Challenging difficulty may deter very young or new players
    • Requires Nintendo Switch console for play
    • Some may find certain levels demanding or frustrating

    Best for: Families or casual players seeking a cooperative platformer with accessible gameplay

    Not ideal for: Advanced players or those wanting a more exploration-based or story-driven Mario game, as it focuses on straightforward platforming

    • Platform:Nintendo Switch
    • Modes:Single-player, Multiplayer
    • Characters:Mario, Luigi, Toadette, Nabbit, Mii characters
    Our verdict
    “This game is ideal for players who enjoy cooperative platforming and family-friendly gameplay on the Switch.”
  8. Super Mario RPG – Nintendo Switch (US Version)

    Super Mario RPG - Nintendo Switch (US Version)

    Best for Classic Turn-Based RPG Fans

    View Latest Price

    Super Mario RPG on Switch stands out for its vibrant, colorful graphics and engaging turn-based combat system, making it a refreshing departure from the more action-oriented Mario games like Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury. Compared to the platform-focused titles, it offers a narrative-driven adventure with strategic battles and exploration. Its small party of three characters allows for tactical decision-making, but the limited details about multiplayer capabilities suggest it’s mainly a single-player experience. The game’s charm lies in its nostalgic appeal and engaging combat, though some players might find the lack of multiplayer or co-op features a drawback. It’s best suited for those who love RPGs with a Mario twist and are willing to indulge in a slower-paced adventure.

    Pros:
    • Vibrant, colorful visuals evoke nostalgic charm
    • Engaging turn-based combat with strategic depth
    • Features a party of three characters for varied gameplay
    Cons:
    • Limited information on multiplayer features, likely single-player only
    • No detailed specifications available for gameplay mechanics
    • May be less appealing to those unfamiliar with RPG genre

    Best for: Fans of RPGs and players seeking a story-rich Mario experience on Switch

    Not ideal for: Players looking for fast-paced action or multiplayer gameplay, as it is primarily single-player

      Our verdict
      “This game suits RPG enthusiasts or Mario fans wanting a story-driven adventure, not a multiplayer party game.”
    • Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury – US Version

      Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury - US Version

      Best for Dual-Adventure Enthusiasts

      View Latest Price

      Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury combines two distinct Mario experiences, appealing to players who enjoy both traditional platforming and open-world challenges. Compared with Super Mario Maker 2, which emphasizes course creation and community sharing, this package offers polished, colorful levels and multiplayer fun in 3D World, along with a new, exciting Bowser’s Fury mode that ramps up the challenge. It supports local and online multiplayer, making it perfect for group play, but its complexity and faster gameplay speeds could be overwhelming for younger players or those unfamiliar with 3D platformers. It’s best for players seeking a comprehensive Mario platforming collection with multiplayer support and fresh content.

      Pros:
      • Includes two popular Mario games in one package
      • Supports both local and online multiplayer modes
      • Features faster character speeds and new levels for added excitement
      Cons:
      • Requires Nintendo Switch console for play
      • Can be complex and challenging for younger or inexperienced players
      • Multiplayer modes may feel overwhelming or hectic for some

      Best for: Players who enjoy dynamic platforming with friends, and want both classic and new Mario adventures in one package

      Not ideal for: Young children or players new to 3D platformers, due to fast-paced gameplay and higher difficulty

      • Platform:Nintendo Switch
      • Game Type:Action, Adventure
      • Multiplayer:Local and online multiplayer
      • Features:Faster character speeds, new levels, Bowser’s Fury mode
      Our verdict
      “This collection is ideal for multiplayer fans seeking classic and modern Mario platforming in a single bundle.”
    • Super Mario Maker 2 – US Version

      Super Mario Maker 2 - US Version

      Best for Creative Builders and Community Sharing

      View Latest Price

      Super Mario Maker 2 stands out for its extensive course creation tools, allowing fans to craft and share a multitude of side-scrolling Mario levels. Compared with Mario Party Superstars, which focuses on multiplayer mini-games, this game emphasizes creativity and community engagement through online sharing and custom levels. Its features like World Maker mode and additional characters foster endless customization, but the learning curve can be steep for newcomers or casual players. Online multiplayer and community access are powerful, yet require a Nintendo Switch Online membership. This title is best suited for players who enjoy designing, sharing, and exploring custom Mario courses, rather than those seeking a straightforward platformer or multiplayer party game.

      Pros:
      • Robust course creation and customization tools
      • Access to a large community for sharing and playing courses
      • Includes new features like World Maker mode and additional characters
      Cons:
      • Requires Nintendo Switch Online membership for online features
      • Learning curve for new creators can be significant
      • Some features depend on software updates or community content

      Best for: Creative players and community enthusiasts eager to design and share custom Mario courses

      Not ideal for: Players who prefer ready-made levels or single-player story modes, as it relies heavily on user-generated content

      • Platform:Nintendo Switch
      • Modes:Single-player, Multiplayer
      • Features:Course creation, Online sharing, Community access, Software updates
      Our verdict
      “This game is perfect for creative players who want to craft and share their own Mario levels and explore a rich community of builders.”
    • Super Mario 3D All-Stars (European Version)

      Super Mario 3D All-Stars (European Version)

      Best for Nostalgic Fans Seeking a Classic Collection with Modern Touches

      View Latest Price

      This collection stands out for consolidating three iconic Mario titles—Super Mario 64, Sunshine, and Galaxy—into one package, making it ideal for players wanting a comprehensive trip through Mario’s 3D adventures. Compared to Super Mario Odyssey, which offers a more modern, open-world experience, Super Mario 3D All-Stars delivers a nostalgic dose of the franchise’s roots with updated graphics on the Switch. However, it’s limited by its regional restrictions in the European version and the lack of additional content or new features, making it less appealing for players seeking fresh experiences. Its strength lies in accessibility and variety, but fans after ongoing updates or extra gameplay modes might find it lacking. In essence, this collection is perfect for those looking to relive classic moments rather than explore new territory.

      Pros:
      • Includes three beloved Mario titles in one package, offering great value
      • Enhanced graphics bring new life to classic gameplay
      • Perfect for fans who want a comprehensive overview of Mario’s 3D evolution
      Cons:
      • Region-specific restrictions limit access for some players
      • Does not include new content or features beyond graphical updates
      • Limited to three games, missing other popular titles like Super Mario 3D World

      Best for: Players wanting a curated, nostalgic compilation of classic 3D Mario games on the Switch

      Not ideal for: Gamers seeking the latest innovations or ongoing content updates in Mario titles

      • Platform:Nintendo Switch
      • Included Games:Super Mario 64, Super Mario Sunshine, Super Mario Galaxy
      • Graphics Update:Yes
      • Region Compatibility:European Version
      • Release Date:2020
      • Content Type:Game Collection
      • Language Options:Multiple (vary by region)
      • Price Range:Mid-tier
      Our verdict
      “This collection is ideal for fans eager to revisit Mario’s most iconic 3D adventures with modern visuals, but not for those wanting the latest or most expansive experience.”
    best Nintendo Mario games
    What makes a great Nintendo Mario game
    1
    Gameplay Style and Genre
    Mario games span a variety of gameplay styles, from traditional side-scrolling platformers to expansive 3D adventures and creative
    2
    Platform and Compatibility
    Most of these titles are designed for the Nintendo Switch, but some older versions and bundles might require specific hardware or
    3
    Single-Player vs. Multiplayer
    Consider whether you prefer solo gaming or multiplayer fun.
    4
    Creative and Innovation Factors
    If you’re seeking something beyond traditional platforming, games like Super Mario Maker 2 give you tools to create your own level
    How to choose your Nintendo Mario game
    1
    How we picked
    We evaluated each game based on gameplay quality, innovation, replayability, accessibility, and platform versatility.
    2
    Gameplay Style and Genre
    Mario games span a variety of gameplay styles, from traditional side-scrolling platformers to expansive 3D adventures an
    3
    Platform and Compatibility
    Most of these titles are designed for the Nintendo Switch, but some older versions and bundles might require specific ha
    4
    Single-Player vs. Multiplayer
    Consider whether you prefer solo gaming or multiplayer fun.
    5
    Creative and Innovation Factors
    If you’re seeking something beyond traditional platforming, games like Super Mario Maker 2 give you tools to create your
    Vetted Nintendo Mario games ·
    The best Nintendo Mario games, compared
    ★ Winner Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder
    Best Overall for Innovative 2D Platforming
    11compared

    How We Picked

    We evaluated each game based on gameplay quality, innovation, replayability, accessibility, and platform versatility. Titles that offer lasting appeal and innovative mechanics ranked higher, while those with limited replay value or platform restrictions fell lower. We also considered how well each game captures the essence of Mario — whether through classic platforming, creative tools, or new storytelling approaches. Our goal was to identify titles that appeal to both dedicated fans and casual players, balancing quality with value. This approach ensures that the ranking reflects what most buyers seek: fun, replayability, and a memorable Mario experience.
    Everyday → specialist
    Everyday & valuePremium & specialist
    Which Nintendo Mario game fits you?
    The everyday user
    All-round, reliable
    The enthusiast
    Premium & high-performance
    The gift-giver
    Looks & craftsmanship

    Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Nintendo Mario Games

    Choosing the best Nintendo Mario game depends on your preferred gameplay style, hardware, and whether you value nostalgia or innovation. Consider how much time you want to invest, if multiplayer features matter, and whether you prefer classic side-scrolling or modern 3D worlds. Budget is another factor, as some titles are included in Nintendo Switch online subscriptions or bundles. Lastly, compatibility with your existing console and whether you enjoy creative or story-driven games can significantly influence your choice.

    Gameplay Style and Genre

    Mario games span a variety of gameplay styles, from traditional side-scrolling platformers to expansive 3D adventures and creative sandbox titles. Decide if you want a straightforward, nostalgic experience or something more innovative like open-world exploration. Games like Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder lean into classic platforming, while Super Mario Odyssey offers a more open-ended adventure. Your choice here will impact how much replayability and freedom you get from the game.

    Platform and Compatibility

    Most of these titles are designed for the Nintendo Switch, but some older versions and bundles might require specific hardware or digital access. Check if the game is compatible with your current console, especially if you own a Switch Lite or other Nintendo devices. Some titles, like Super Mario 3D All-Stars, are available as part of larger collections, which might influence your decision based on platform preference and availability.

    Single-Player vs. Multiplayer

    Consider whether you prefer solo gaming or multiplayer fun. Titles like Mario Party Superstars excel for multiplayer sessions, while Super Mario Odyssey and Super Mario Galaxy focus on immersive single-player campaigns. Some games, such as Super Mario Maker 2, allow multiplayer sharing and community features, adding layers of engagement that could sway your choice.

    Value and Content Depth

    Price varies, especially with digital bundles or subscriptions like Nintendo Switch Online. Some titles, like Super Mario 3D All-Stars, offer collections that provide multiple games at a better value, while others are stand-alone. Think about how much content you want — longer campaigns, creative tools, or multiplayer modes — and whether the price matches the longevity and replayability offered.

    Creative and Innovation Factors

    If you’re seeking something beyond traditional platforming, games like Super Mario Maker 2 give you tools to create your own levels, adding a creative dimension. Conversely, Super Mario Odyssey introduces new mechanics and worlds that refresh the franchise for longtime fans. Understanding whether you want to experience new gameplay innovations or stick with classic mechanics will help narrow your options.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Which Mario game is best for newcomers to the franchise?

    Super Mario Odyssey is an excellent starting point because of its accessible controls, engaging open-world exploration, and welcoming design. It introduces key elements of Mario gameplay without overwhelming players with complexity. Its vibrant worlds and creative mechanics make it enjoyable for players new to the franchise while still offering depth for seasoned fans. If you prefer a more traditional experience, Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder provides a straightforward, classic platforming adventure.

    Are digital collections like Super Mario 3D All-Stars worth buying?

    Digital collections such as Super Mario 3D All-Stars can offer great value if you want multiple titles bundled together, especially at a discounted price. They provide access to a variety of classic games that have stood the test of time, making them ideal for fans who want a broad Mario experience. However, these collections may lack the latest gameplay innovations and are sometimes limited in availability, so consider whether you prioritize modern features or classic nostalgia. Additionally, if you already own some titles separately, the collection might be less appealing.

    What should I consider if I want multiplayer Mario games?

    Multiplayer Mario titles like Mario Party Superstars and Super Mario Maker 2 excel in social play, whether locally or online. If multiplayer fun is your priority, look for games that support multiple players simultaneously and offer diverse modes. Keep in mind that some titles are better suited for casual gaming with friends, while others include competitive or cooperative features that enhance replayability. Compatibility with multiple controllers and online features can also influence your overall experience.

    Is it better to buy Mario games digitally or physically?

    Choosing between digital and physical copies depends on your preferences for convenience, storage, and collection. Digital downloads provide instant access and save physical space, but they require sufficient storage and can’t be resold. Physical copies are tangible collectibles, often come with artwork, and can be traded or sold later. If you frequently upgrade consoles or value portability, digital might suit you better, but for collectors or those who prefer a physical library, discs or cartridges are worth considering.

    How do I select a Mario game if I have limited gaming time?

    If your gaming sessions are short, look for titles with shorter campaigns or quick-play modes, such as Super Mario Run or Mario Party Superstars. These games often feature bite-sized levels or mini-games that can be enjoyed in brief intervals. Conversely, if you prefer longer experiences, titles like Super Mario Odyssey or Super Mario Galaxy offer more extensive adventures but may require dedicated sessions to fully enjoy. Matching game length with your available gaming time ensures a more satisfying experience.

    Conclusion

    For the most comprehensive experience, Super Mario Odyssey remains the best overall pick, offering a blend of innovation and classic charm. Budget-conscious players will appreciate Super Mario 3D All-Stars for its collection value. Newcomers should start with Super Mario Odyssey or Super Mario Bros.™ Wonder for accessible gameplay. Fans seeking creative tools should consider Super Mario Maker 2. For multiplayer fun, Mario Party Superstars ticks all the boxes, while those looking for a premium, feature-rich experience might prefer the latest releases on the Switch.
    You May Also Like

    9 Best Smart Power Strip With Energy Monitoring in 2026

    Discover the best smart power strips with energy monitoring in 2026. Find top picks for performance, value, and smart home integration in this detailed guide.

    15 Best Wireless Earbuds for Fitness in 2026

    Discover the top wireless earbuds for fitness in 2026. Find the best options for durability, sound, comfort, and value to enhance your workouts.

    13 Best Smart Meat Thermometers in 2026

    Discover the top smart meat thermometers of 2026. Find the best overall, value picks, and specialized options for perfect grilling and cooking.

    10 Best Smart Rings for Fitness Tracking in 2025: Oura Ring 4 and More

    A comprehensive guide to the top smart rings for fitness tracking in 2025, including the Oura Ring 4 and more, to help you find your perfect match.