TL;DR
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Matter Alpha reports that its writer spent the first month in a new apartment replacing most older Zigbee devices with Matter products for lighting, controls and other smart-home functions. The account describes a mixed experience: the setup is in use, but Matter-exposed switches lack features the writer relied on, and the report does not establish how every device category performed.
Matter Alpha has published a first-month report from a writer who replaced most of an older Zigbee smart-home setup with Matter devices in a new apartment. The account describes equipment across lighting, wall controls, climate, sensors and power monitoring, but says some Matter-connected switches currently lack features the writer needs for day-to-day use.
The writer says the move created an opportunity to rebuild the system rather than carry forward a collection of older devices and protocols. They reused existing network credentials and restarted their main controllers, while clearing out many old device entries. Some standalone bridges were retired because they were no longer needed for the writer’s reduced Zigbee use; software options including eWeLink Cube and Homey Self-Hosted Server were used to bring certain proprietary local-network devices into Matter.
For new Matter devices, the writer says they use Home Assistant as the primary controller. Devices intended for manual phone control are shared with Apple Home, while Home Assistant’s cloud service is used to connect with Google Home and Amazon Alexa. This is the writer’s particular arrangement, not a claim that every Matter installation needs the same controller combination.
Lighting and wall controls came first. The writer reports installing about 10 Aqara Thread switches and dimmers to control fans, lights and ceiling fixtures, alongside ceiling lights, pendant fixtures, light strips and smart bulbs from several manufacturers. Their assessment is that the switches have not yet improved on their Zigbee counterparts for the features they use: the Matter interface lacks decoupled relay mode, and dimmer configuration options are limited. The report says the setup is being used while the writer considers other options for wall boxes without neutral wiring.
Where Matter Falls Short for Switches
The report offers a practical view of interoperability versus feature depth. Matter is intended to let compatible devices work across smart-home platforms, and the writer’s setup uses multiple controllers and brands. But the account suggests that access through a common standard may not expose every manufacturer-specific control a user expects.
That distinction matters for people planning a renovation or replacing switches. A device may join a Matter system and perform basic control while still lacking a particular automation mode or configuration option. The writer’s experience is a single household report, not a controlled comparison or a measure of how all Matter switches perform. It does, however, show why shoppers should check both platform compatibility and the specific functions available through their chosen controller.
Products Worth Considering
LG UltraGear 27-Inch QHD OLED Gaming Monitor, 240Hz, 0.03ms, G-SYNC Compatible, FreeSync Premium Pro, HDMI 2.1
Bose QuietComfort Wireless Noise-Cancelling Over-Ear Headphones, Black
Sonos Era 100 Wireless Smart Speaker, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
A Rebuild Around Matter Controllers
The writer began with an established smart-home setup spanning major ecosystems, then used the move to reduce reliance on older Zigbee devices. They say they retained largely the same network credentials, powered their main controllers back on and removed many legacy device entries. This means the account is about replacing device infrastructure within an existing smart-home environment, rather than starting with no controller or network.
The article identifies lighting and wall controls as the first priorities because they are used frequently in the apartment. Its examples include Aqara switches, Govee and Nanoleaf ceiling lights, IKEA fixtures and bulbs, and products from other brands. The report also lists climate, sensors and power monitoring among the areas addressed, but the supplied material gives much less detail about those categories than about lighting.
““They are no better than their Zigbee counterparts over Matter right now.””
— Matter Alpha writer
Performance Beyond the Lighting Setup
The supplied report does not provide a full performance assessment of every device category named. It does not give detailed results for the climate devices, sensors or power-monitoring equipment, nor does it quantify reliability, response times, outages or maintenance over the month. The writer’s switch criticism is specific to their products, controller setup and desired functions; it should not be read as a finding about every Matter device.
It is also unclear from the supplied material which exact Matter features are unavailable because of the standard, a manufacturer implementation, or the controller interface. The report does not provide a complete inventory of devices or independent test data. Its account is based on the writer’s experience in one apartment.
More Use, and a Switch Search
The writer says they are continuing to use the installed switches while looking for alternatives that support neutral-free wiring and offer the controls they want. Further use may show whether the current limitations can be addressed through software updates, different controller settings or replacement hardware, but the report does not announce a specific update or product change.
For readers considering a similar setup, the immediate next step is to compare the functions a device exposes in the intended smart-home platform—not just its Matter compatibility label. The article’s broader account of climate, sensor and power-monitoring devices would be needed to judge how the rest of the apartment’s system performed after its first month.
Key Questions
What did the writer set up during the first month?
The writer reports adding Matter devices across several categories, including lighting and wall controls, as well as climate, sensors and power monitoring. The supplied report gives the most detail about lighting.
Which controller did the writer use first?
The writer says they start adding new Matter devices through Home Assistant, then share selected devices with Apple Home and use Home Assistant’s cloud service for Google Home and Amazon Alexa.
What problem did the writer report with the switches?
The writer says the Matter-connected Aqara switches lacked decoupled relay mode for smart-bulb automations and offered limited dimmer configuration through Matter. This is the writer’s experience with their setup, not a universal test of all switches.
Did the writer remove every Zigbee device?
No. The account says the writer replaced most of the older Zigbee gear and retired some bridges, but it does not state that every Zigbee device was removed.
Does the report show that an all-Matter home is fully reliable?
No. It is a first-person account from one apartment and does not provide quantified reliability data or detailed results for every device category.
Source: rss
